REMtrospective, 9: Out of Time
Released on: March 11, 1991
Favorite tracks: “Radio Song,” “Losing My Religion,” “Low,” “Country Feedback”
Out of Time represents a peak for REM. It’s one of their most commercially successful of their albums, with “Losing My Religion” being their biggest hit single and possibly their “most famous” song. It turned the band from a popular college/alternative act to a popular mainstream band.
And Out of Time took REM to the big-time without compromising their artistic integrity, unless you count the ever-increasing intelligibility of Stipe’s singing to be a compromise. It’s like the listening audience finally “got” REM - or maybe REM and the audience met each other halfway. Because the band’s sound definitely changed. Looking back at Chronic Town, Murmur and Reckoning, it’s amazing how different the band sounds. The philosophy of songwriting, the prominence of the vocals, Buck’s once-trademark guitar style - all have gone through a transition. But it’s a “the same, only different” kind of transformation: I recognize the songs as “REM songs” (which is not something I’d say for Automatic for the People).
It’s interesting to compare them in this regard to U2, college-rock contemporaries turned arena rock acts. U2’s sound has evolved too, and they’ve dabbled in different directions, but they’ve remained in a narrower continuum than REM ever did.
Does “Losing My Religion” qualify as one of the most unlikely hit singles of all time? The Wikipedia entry has this quote: “According to Peter Buck, when Warner Bros. heard the album that was to take them to the top, they were dumbfounded: “You think the one with the lead mandolin should be the first single?!”“